Friday, November 25, 2016

Relegation is not the answer in MLS



In America, we have a thing of being different, as in the case of calling the beautiful game of football soccer and so far with three professional leagues and Major League Soccer being its main one and seen as its first division.

The league that started in 1996, so far has grown from ten squads to 23 and with many suitors waiting for the yay from its league commissioner.

The North American Soccer League follows it as a second division and the third division considered as a formative association in the United Soccer League, and the NPSL as a sort of fourth tier, completes the pyramid of professional leagues in the United States.

However, the prospects of creating a system similar to other European and Latin American leagues for now are considering this idea as a long time project not feasible to implement to MLS for now! 

However, despite the existence of these three entities, in the States, the system of promotion and relegation is nonexistent.

As the question arises in many USL and NASL squads not having their own venues to call home and using college or other parks to play their matches, this will constitute a certain risk for Major league Soccer.

Whenever Don Garber announces the arrival of a new franchise, these coming from the NASL or USL, these new squads, have to pay a 100 million fee to the league and with the compromise of building their own venue to play.

If a relegation system is implemented this could mean disaster to Americas top soccer association and its prospective parties interested in bringing a new franchise to their city, will deterred them in doing such an endeavor.

With the LACFC building its own stadium to present itself in 2017, these squads do not waste anytime already marketing their season passes and generating a demand, thanks to the growing interest of the game in America.

Alongside newcomers Atlanta and Minnesota United as the first one already has a place to call home for its sister team the NFL Atlanta Falcons and for the Minnesota squad already planning to build in Saint Paul a place to call home.

One day before a match here in Portland’s Providence Park, I spoke to a local TV sportscaster and he told me his negative and the minuses of this crazy idea of seeing this relegation- promotion nonsense in his mind.

Very well, he stated that if the Carolina Railhawks or Charlotte Battery get lucky and get the nod for first division, how they would compete with 5000 seating capacity stadiums against 20,000 plus stadiums already in place in MLS.

 In addition, another expert expresses it as a crazy idea and completely dismissing it.
On the other hand, in the case of USL FC Cincinnati already breaking all sorts of attendance records, currently considered by MLS as a possible incorporation into its ranks, as well St. Louis, San Antonio and Sacramento these two with their own venues.

Making room to an expansion if these get the call from MLS top operate Don Garber, they can make modifications to their venues of making serious expansions to its seating capacity.

Still for NASL top man Bill Peterson and NPSL Joe Barone have publicly expressed their desires of putting this system in place, in the case of MLS commissioner Don Garber his silence says a lot.

With the game growing in an accelerated pace and seeing its acceptance in many parts of the US as the case of the Pacific Northwest in Seattle- breaking all sorts of attendance records and since its inception has held this title uninterruptedly.

As well the Portland Timbers constant sellouts as well Vancouver these considered the Cascadia three, very well NYCFC, Orlando FC and SKC have shown their passion for the game too with impressive numbers in their parks.

Being this game in its formative stages and for many newcomer followers of several MLS squads, how will they understand the prospects of seeing a relegation and promotion for their squads? As for Chicago these with back to back not so positive campaigns, they would be top candidates to make it  into the abyss.

Alongside what once was a powerhouse and a hardened squad in the Houston Dynamo, their fan base would turn their back to their squad if these would become relegated, after all Houston and Dallas are known to post not so positive and notable attendances.

As both the Fire and Dynamo having not so stellar campaigns, as well Colorado and others finishing in the bottom, they would be in the chop block and not welcome by their fan base.

For now leave it like it is and see this possibility as a long-term project, for now Soccer has already caught the eye of many Americans in love with their traditional sports in football, basketball and baseball.

In addition, some of these turning their backs to the game will be in part disastrous.
The ball is on the table and for a long time this debate will continue and become a heated piece in the center of US Soccer federation and its professional leagues, will it work, maybe but why not institute it with the NASL, USL and that unofficial NPSL.

In the case of Major League Soccer, let’s leave this association out of this and let it grow as it has plan and institute in its Managers the culture of using the academies in these leagues to promote and develop future players.

The coin is in the air!

Do you think MLS will be up to the challenge along its squads of a promotion and relegation method, is this debatable subject and to place in a matter of time, what is your intake for such a risky endeavor?

 
Post Contents and Property of Fern Mc Costigan © Copyright All Rights Reserved  

Photos Credit, Courtesy and Property of © MLS, USL and  NASL 2016     


No comments:

Post a Comment